Thursday, March 08, 2007

365

Happy International Women's Day

Happy Blogiversary to me. OK, it's not really my blogiversary. Tomorrow is. Today is simply day #365 as a blogger. When I was a youngin' growing up in Ontario, the learner's permit that you got so that you could drive a car was called a "365"; it allowed you 1 year in which to practice before you had to take the driving test. Pass the test and get your license; refuse to take the test or fail it before the deadline and your learner's permit would expire.

And so, on this, my last day as an apprentice blogger, I plan to take the test. It's an all or nothing, single essay question worth 100%

On International Women's Day, how would you theorize blogging as related to feminism and motherhood? You have 1 hour to complete the test before you must fold laundry and help wash dishes. Begin.

(insert: I tried to complete the test in my blogging hour but it was just too big. When my husband came home from work, it took me over a half an hour just to explain all that I was hoping to write. This means that there will be installments over the next week or so. I did make a decent go at the beginnings of it all and maybe the comment discussion will open up the rest of the conversation. Please tell me that I didn't fail. Please don't take my learner's permit away.)

Let me begin with a quotation from that first post a year ago:

"While the wage gap between women and men is still so pronounced, here in the blogosphere we have the multiple voices of unpaid women--unpaid as mothers but, more to my point, unpaid as writers--offering up their talents free of charge: speaking because they need a voice NOT because that voice will be heard, recognized, or remunerated. It's an age-old story. Women do what women must and the economy largely ignores them despite being utterly dependent on them.

When I studied English literature years and years ago, I learned a little about the rise of the woman novelist in the 18th century. So many women flocking to a new genre that afforded them room to speak. Some, like Charlotte Smith, found writing novels distasteful--their true calling being poetry. But alas, novels paid the bills and with a good-for-nothing husband (she left because she "feared her life was not safe") and 12 children, she did what she had to.

And so we now have another new genre and throngs of wired women looking for that room of their own. Most will go unheard, many will be heard but unrecognized but, with hope, a few will not only gain influence but will also be well-rewarded for their efforts."

This is how I saw the parenting blogosphere through my idealized eye one short year ago. So much has changed in my thinking yet so much remains the same.

Back then I modeled blogging on conventional career paths and tied it to the economy. I never thought of myself as someone who wanted to be or would be remunerated for my writing but I did think that some of the bloggers I read would go on to make money in the more conventional fields of journalism, freelance writing, and creative writing. In short, I saw blogging as a means to an end. I did not see it as an end in itself. I didn't know about adSense or career blogging then; I was a babe in the woods. I'm still a babe in the woods.

A year later, I do see blogging as an end in itself. The parenting blogosphere is a strong community (or a community of separate communities that overlap and are as complexly interwoven as that cable-knit sweater in my last post). Although this community is not exclusively made up of women, it is a female-intensive space and like most female-intensive spaces, it tends to be undervalued by society. Conventional articles in newspapers and magazines usually deride mommy bloggers as scribbling women who are not adequately attentive to their children, who egomaniacally place their needs above those of their children, who think of their children as fashion accessories and who recklessly compromise their children's privacy to serve their own ends. The fact that the parenting blogosphere has created an alternative means for distilling received wisdom on child rearing practices is usually ignored in the conventional media. The fact that mothers are communicating with other mothers in a way that is articulate and wise is overlooked. The fact that parents turn to the blogosphere because they spend their evenings attentive to crib monitors rather than frivolity is not really mentioned. The fact that family life has become increasingly fractured and broad-based community support of new parents has been eroded over the last few decades is also not mentioned.

You see, to acknowledge these things would be to acknowledge that something quite revolutionary has sprung up here. Mothers (gasp!!) have taken back their authority to mother from the experts; the parenting books are now being read simply as supplements, not gospels. Yes, blogging mothers have recreated much of the support network that has always been a vital part of parenting. They have gained confidence in their roles as mothers and have crafted a sense of agency to think and act as women integrated in the various mantles they are forced to adopt (employee, mother, wife, intellectual, activist...). In short, they have created a whole new set of operating instructions for what it means to be a mother.

I end with this question: why are the fellows who developed Linux (a distributed, cooperative, free operating system) hailed as heroes of the computer age--Robin Hoods in a world of Gatesian monopolies--while the women (primarily) who have developed a counter-culture discourse to pseudo-scientific parenting considered reckless egomaniacs?

OK, that's all I could muster tonight. There will be more installments, I'm afraid. I have a lot, lot, lot that I still want to say.

35 hats in the ring:

mo-wo said...

I want to change my tagline to 'reckless egomaniac!'

and, did you ever see that Marg Delahunty bit... About IWD.. Women make up 50%+ of the population Everday is International Women's Day!

Nice post sister.

Jennifer (ponderosa) said...

This is so long I should have posted it on my own blog. But here you go.

Blogging and conversing verballing serve much the same purpose for me. Both can be a means to an end -- acquiring information, giving information, building consensus, etc. -- but there's also a joy in it. It's fun.

Because I work part-time now & can't visit with my friends very much, and because my husband can't give me much of his time, I blog instead of talking. I blog as a way of codifying my thinking. You could say that I don't know what I think until I write it down... I don't publish every post I write. In fact less than half. Because often, the act of writing (or even composing a post in my head) is enough. I've thought out what I need to think out & I feel better.

I believe that blogging & the community it provides to lonely mothers up at odd hours -- I believe that's valuable. I mean, I've been at it for 2 years now. But I don't believe it's any more revolutionary than a playgroup in which the women talk straight talk about parenting. I do believe that the real-life examples given on blogs and among women IRL are way, way more powerful & influential than anything written in a manual.

Women are very good at creating informal networks to provide each other with the support that society is not giving them. Parenting blogs are one example; playgroups are another. I am part of a "babysitting coop" that's really just a group of 7 families that swap time watching each other's kids. And then there's the teenage babysitter who's paid under the table... All of these are ways that we modern parents try to survive in a fractured, suspicious society that doesn't value caregiving.

As for your final question: You know who else are considered reckless egomaniacs? Women in playgroups who drink or otherwise enjoy themselves. Parenting is supposed to SUCK! Everyone knows that. It's all about poop and puke and getting woken at midnight for 18 years. If you're having fun, you're either simpleminded or you're not doing it right! -- I would say that parent blogging is undervalued because parenting is undervalued.

slouching mom said...

Since I started blogging two or three months ago, twice I have heard, "You might think about getting some of this into print." (Isn't it already in print?) And both times, the speaker was male. To my mind this is not a coincidence.

slouching mom said...

Oh, and Happy Blog Anniversary!

Sober Briquette said...

Your test results are being withheld until you blog for another 365 days.

Em said...

Wow! I think blogging is an end in itself for me too... and like jennifer says - it gives me a formula in which I can structure my thoughts and clarify my thinking... the community aspect is important too - because without it, I wouldn't stick around.

cinnamon gurl said...

I think blogging is potentially more subversive than the playgroups jennifer ponderosa compares it with. The thing about blogging is that it IS a form of publishing. And I think that's why it's different than playgroups. Plus, a playgroup where I can be as honest and as supported as I am here in blogland, is a rare playgroup. Many times the talk sticks to 'safe' subjects like milestones, growth, and things like that. But yes, talking to certain other mothers IRL is very very important to me.

This is a great post, and I can't wait for the next installment(s).

I have to think more on your question. It's a great one.

NotSoSage said...

Up too late blogging, watching episodes of L0st and fielding Joe's requests of "Why can't you just suspend disbelief and enjoy it?" and responding that this is how I enjoy a show.

Sorry, totally off topic, but I don't feel smart enough to make a comment on topic right now. I just wanted to wish you a Happy 365!!! Good thing you missed graduated licensing...I think you've broken all those rules at one time or another: blogging on major highways, blood alcohol level higher than 0, with some passengers not wearing seatbelts.

Okay, I'll leave you alone now.

Mad Hatter said...

Jennifer, I agree that one of the reasons I blog is that it helps me structure my thought. I usually don't know what I am going to write until I start writing either.

I do believe though that the parenting blogosphere is truly revolutionary and I hope that by the time I finish all the installments in this series I will have proven my point. I know this is an unfair comment back b/c it forces you to wait. What I do know, though, is that I have not yet proven the point.

Jennifer (ponderosa) said...

Mad -- well now you can be sure I'll be refreshing bloglines all day long : )

Mad Hatter said...

Oh Jen, please bear with me. The Just Posts are coming up on the weekend and I want to write a Monday style challenge and, and, and, I am at work right now. I think I will get back to this early next week. 'kay?

Mimi said...

Most of the treatments of / public thinking about mommyblogging occur in the mass media--and we know how nuanced and sophisticated their readings of the online world can be: drunken mommies! hipster solipsism! babes in rude t-shirts! This is not a forum for careful thinking about what gets done in the momosphere.

What academic work on the blogosphere exists tends to focus on blogs about politics and media, and the life-writing genres of blog meet with very little attention from mainstream media studies ... They're all writing about the tip of the iceberg, not the 95% of the blogosphere that looks like us. Why? Because politics are media are serious, and mommy bloggers are so many self-absorbed private diarists. Deprecation of this kind of writing is not unique to online media. Oh well. Since I am in fact an academic researcher of new media, as well as a mommyblogger, I'm working on addressing this lack, ladies, I'm working on it ... even though I'm more trained (of course!) in the politics-and-media angles.

Into the breach! Keep those posts coming--when you can!--Mad.

NotSoSage said...

Mimi...I think we've found a new direction for your career! :)

Susanne said...

Happy 365. And in blogging years you have been driving much longer than a year...

Thank you for writing about this. I'm looking forward to the rest of it.

metro mama said...

Comparing mommy blogging to Linus--brilliant.

Great post.

Kyla said...

Spectacular. I completely agree with you. My post earlier into the week went into my personal reasons for blogging and the way it has helped me process things and cope, but it has also opened my eyes in an incredible way to things I would never have thought about otherwise. It truly has the potential to be revolutionary and that potential grows every day. I will be eager to read the further installments when you get around to them, Mad.

Mary G said...

Good stuff. Really good stuff. I really envy you the community; I was dying in the desert for something like this when my kids were little. Thirty-five years ago. *ouch* The levels of intelligence, research, creativity, generosity are awesome, as the teenaged grandson would say. 365 congratulations.

Jennifer (ponderosa) said...

Mad, you do make me think!

Question for you (and the audience): is the "parenting blogosphere" currently limited to people with children preschool age or younger? If so, why?

bubandpie said...

I think of blogging as really-good-playgroup-plus. The support, the sharing of information, the community aspects are important - but there is also a kind of introspection and theorizing that can occur in the blogosphere that would not really be suitable for the back-and-forth of a playgroup conversation, and certainly does not go on in the parenting discourse produced by mainstream media like the parenting magazines, most of which focus almost exclusively on practical tips.

bubandpie said...
This post has been removed by the author.
Oh, The Joys said...

We are pioneers I think.

nomotherearth said...

I'm with B&P...it's hard to have these kind of conversations while running after toddlers and wiping noses, but it doesn't mean that I don't have these thoughts and don't want to share them. So I end up obsessing about ideas in my head. Now I have an outlet for them. Even with blogging, I'm looking for a better way to express my thoughts.

Your blog, I believe, is a model of excellent impassioned writing. Happy 365!

Beck said...

Well, I'm very glad you do blog, whatever the reason. For me, motherhood created a whole new world and yet there aren't a lot of real life opportunities to talk about how life changing it all is.
Plus, I like the attention. What's so bad about liking attention? I mean, look at figure skating - a whole sport based around "I am so pretttty!" and yet you never hear angry diatribes about it (aside from this one).

Mary G said...

Re Jennifer's query as to who is eligible for the parenting blogosphere. I sometimes feel guilty for being here even though I have a part time three year old to grandmother, so I've been wondering too. I feel as if I am and always will be a mother, but, thank goodness, I stay out of the trenches most of the time. Looking forward to your thoughts on the question.

Mary G said...

Re Jennifer's query as to who is eligible for the parenting blogosphere. I sometimes feel guilty for being here even though I have a part time three year old to grandmother, so I've been wondering too. I feel as if I am and always will be a mother, but, thank goodness, I stay out of the trenches most of the time. Looking forward to your thoughts on the question.

kgirl said...

god you're smart. will come back and reread when i'm feeling smart.

Mad Hatter said...

Mary G and Jennifer. I don't think the parenting blogosphere is restrictive per se. (although one of the installments in this series that I want to write is precisely about it being restrictive but that's a whole other kettle of fish that I'll get to later).

I have people who read and comment here who have grown children, who have grandchildren, and who have no children. Most have infants or toddlers but many have school-age kids and adolescents. However, I do think that there are more parents with young children blogging. This is likely b/c parenting blogging has only come of age in the last two years, b/c parents with babes who still nap have a bit of flexibility with when they can write, b/c parents of really young children spend more time on-line desperate to find answers and are more likely to stumble into blogging, b/c parents of older children sometimes struggle more with issues of privacy (their kids can find and read their blogs) and finally, b/c the mass media has marketed mommyblogging as something that pertains to the new-parent set. How's that for a long-winded answer?

Mary G said...

Comprehensive! Thanks....I'm not sure I could make myself stop reading your posts. They're addictive.

jen said...

i'll take reckless egomaniac and raise you by one fantastical odessey, Jane.

Er, I mean, Mad.

Jenifer G. said...

So so dizzy. So so many things to say. Happy Blogiversary to start.

Smart comments on another installment I promise!

Her Bad Mother said...

Women are taking back their authority in their own spaces. THAT's what's revolutionary.

Well said. I'll be taking this up myself, as Joy and I prepare for conferences where we're addressing these questions, and will certainly link back here.

(I don't know if you've seen our blogrhet page - Blog Rhetoric? www.blogrhet.blogspot.com - ground central for our 'academibloggy' approach to these questions.)

Redneck Mommy said...

Brilliant. I can't wait to read the next installment, Mad.

You've got my blood pumping with this post.

And happy Blogiversary to you!

You Are My Sunshine said...

The more I read the more I learn… Well said! Waiting for the next part.

gingajoy said...

Mad. Can I kiss you?
There are several points here I had not thought about, or not in sufficient depth. First--I find it interesting that so many among our particular group (mainly you canadians, actually) started this thing as "room of one's own"--and also a way to write. Be A Writer. And that that thinking has evolved over the first year of writing.

Ok--my babe is crying. Must go. I'll be back with more comments tomorrow/later.

(but the issue of how support systems are eroded now--YES. had not thought of it in these terms).

gingajoy said...

in response to ponderosa's "In that sense, comments are not always an indicator of the intrinsic merit of the post, though of course all of us feel they are (and tell ourselves they're not)."

I would agree-we're not necessarily coming up with something radically new in terms of message, but the medium of the blog allows that message--the subordinated one--the be put out there. In writing. For others to find and connect (or not) with. In this way blogging is more than community building, it's a form of publication for consumption. It performs a function outside of the networking aspect.