When Jess posted about death the other day, I left one of those icky, petulant comments that sometimes those of us who have suffered certain kinds of loss can spew out unwittingly. I've been thinking quite a bit about it ever since: death, that is, and my latent ability to come to terms with it, not my own propensity for petulance. The truth is, my father's death changed everything, EVERYTHING, not just my understanding of mortality.
My dad died of Hodgkins disease when I was 7. He was sick for a long time beforehand such that my memories of him are vague and few. I remember riding up the gravel laneway in the back of his blue pick up truck. There was the time he spanked me--and good--for not listening to him. I remember his sickness and the days and weeks he lay in bed too weak to move. Oh, and I definitely remember the revolting carbuncle he developed on his back. My final glimpse of him was the day the ambulance carried his skeletal frame away. He would die a couple of weeks later. That's it. The sum total of what I remember of the man who was my parent for seven years.
I have every reason to believe my dad was a good man, a decent man. That's what my siblings remember. Brusque yet funny, he identified with Fred Flintstone. His favourite song was My Old Brown Coat and Me as sung by Doc Williams. His days were completely given over to farming before he took a union job to pay the bills when he got sick. He once told my older brother, "Ronnie, I've got nothing against Led personally, I just don't like his music." Ron, I'm sure, let Mr. Zepplin know.
Through our farm, Dad represented the sole income, the sole lifeline for a wife and six children. Is it any wonder that my mom once told me that on the day of his funeral, she had an overwhelming urge to jump into the coffin with him, to die right then and there?
We sold the farm when I was 4; he was already sick by then.
On the day he died, Mom came home from the hospital and gathered us kids together in the driveway. She told us that dad had died. I didn't get it at all. I didn't understand one whit until I saw my older siblings crying. This was late June, 1973. Come fall, I headed back to school where I was passed around like bruised fruit. I had no idea why teachers gently pulled me aside to make sure I knew I could confide in them. All I wanted was to get back to class and get the week's words for spelling dictation. None of it made sense.
Throughout my childhood, our family made do. We ate. We had clothes, heat, electricity and a fairly reliable car. Somehow we made do and that's all that really needs to be said on the matter. When it came time for University, Trudeau's Liberals gave this orphan (their term on the paperwork) tuition money and a bit more besides. I really do have social democracy to thank for all I have. In fact, if Dad had lived I doubt I would have been able to afford the opportunities I received.
But here's the thing: while I was away at university, I started having disturbing recurring dreams about my dad. There was the one where I would dig underneath our house in an attempt to find a tunnel out, only to stumble upon his bones instead. In another he had never really died but came back to our family in order to block me at every step. The final dream was always violent and recurred more than the others. In it I would stand on my front lawn surrounded by all the men in my family. These men that I trusted and loved raised guns and shot at my knee-caps until I woke up screaming in pain and fear.
In my mid-twenties, these dreams stopped but I've never known what to make of them. Did it really take me 20 years to internalize his death and then let it work itself out from my sub-conscious? Was I a little too isolated and terrified as a female undergraduate, the first ever in my family? Was I becoming keenly aware of the economic and social structures that had determined my life? I really don't know.
The only photograph of my entire family. I'm beside Dad, down front.
Jess's post and Jen's follow-up brought these memories all back in a rush and I knew I wouldn't be content until I had set them down somewhere. I no longer worry about the dreams or their import. What I do fret about is that fickle beast, memory. My dad died when I was seven and I retain precisely four memories of him. My daughter is three. She is just leaving her infant amnesia years. Until now I have been her everything and yet, if I died tomorrow, she would simply cease to remember me one day--not just my smell or the sound of my singing but everything about me and my love for her. What's more, she might even learn to cope by internalizing me as a spectre, a sinister shadow that would one day haunt her dreams.
Friday, April 25, 2008
Shadows
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)


































40 hats in the ring:
Mad, it's ridiculously late (you write blog posts at 1:30 AM too hmm?) but I had to write and just say thank you for sharing your dad with us, and your kid's heart and dreams, and how this makes you reflect as a mama.
What really got me was the poster for the sale of the farm... I don't know why. I imagine all his hard work, and all of you, and my heart stops.
xo
Wow. This was a very powerful - and spooky - post. And yeah, that poster made me teary, too.
mad, this makes me want to learn more, to know your dad, what he liked to eat, how he walked. i can't imagine what that has been like for you all these years.
and the bravery in that alone. and your mom.
mad.
Memory is so ... transient, ultimately. I've been thinking a lot about this lately, myself and while the rational part of me wants to say that the reason we forget is so that our load of hurt doesn't grind us into the ground such that we can't move forward ... how can it be that nevertheless we feel this strange loss for that which we don't feel anymore? Pain for absent pain?
When my dad died, as I've told you, I was relieved. Relieved because it meant that that 25 year wound could start, blessedly, to close over, to recede. I do feel guilty about that, and awkward. My parents divorced when I was 4, and I have about just as many clear memories of my dad from that era as you do. Indistinct, brief, impressionistic.
the poster for the sale got me too, Mad. as did the dreams...the trying to work it out. it's been my own experience that a great deal of the unprocessed loss that had been my "normal" growing up needed to work itself out come college and my twenties, too...i think it was a part of my "becoming" as an adult that i had to finally internalize and work through the spectres, for myself.
and yet, your dad...with no choice in his leaving...this haunts me as a parent. the terrible thing about death, i think sometimes, is that we eventually heal from it, that we are, ultimately, fragile and temporal in so many ways.
i have very vague memories of my mom, who left when i was eight, but my lack of memory is for different reasons (survival).
this post moved me to tears - especially thinking about my own child whose seven and knowing if something happened to me, her memories would equally be vague.
This is a haunting post.
This is one of the reasons I continue to blog. I like to think that if something happened to me, Jane could still get to know me, just a little bit.
First, I took none of the connotation you suggest from you comment - so rest easy on that front.
This post is haunting and beautiful.
As others have said, very haunting indeed.
So many of my friends lost their fathers at a young age, and I've heard many of the same things that you write about - mothers overextended and heartbroken and exhausted, the terrible feeling of having too few memories of their fathers, resentment of older siblings who had TIME with this now absent-father. It's scary.
(((Mad)))
Oh Mad - the arc of your father and you to you and your child - so haunting and hard. I feel for you.
that echoing ache...those dreams that creep in for years later..sometimes it does that that long, especially that young.
Your parents dreams for themselves, and for all of you, shattered..I just can't imagine. Not to the degree that that poster illuminates.
hugs.
Wow. You give me chills, yanno?
The poster and the photo... they choke me up almost as much as the prose.
(((Mad)))
The loss of a parent is always one of the biggest scars I her about from people.
This was, as has been said, very moving and haunting.
I identify pretty well with this post. My father died of a brain tumor when he was 3. He, too, was sick my whole life, but he was diagnosed as having epilepsy. He was supposed to have been drafted, but in the early 60s men with families were exempted. Had he been drafted, the tumor would have been discovered far earlier and removed sooner, and he may have lived. Like you, I was too young to grieve properly, though Mom did say that I cried for Daddy to come home for a couple of weeks. I have been less afraid for my children that I would die, but that their father would. There were only 2 of us, but my father's death greatly limited opportunities for my brother and me. There was also the spectre of trying to live up to the image of a man who achieved sainthood immediately upon dying. I have tried to move past that bitterness by recognizing that had he lived, my life might have gone in a different direction and I might not be where I am with my wonderful husband and gorgeous children. I try to do a lot of writing so that if something does happen to either or both of us, our children will always know FROM OUR WORDs and not other people's, how much we love them and wanted them. Sorry I ran on.
Wow. So many parallel thoughts on this plane....
I've written and deleted all my thoughts. I just want to honor what you've "put down" here.
It's achingly familiar.
The poster is very sad, but it's the photo that gets me. It's like you all are in one world, and your dad is in a completely different one. Kind of like he's been photoshopped in. Eerie.
Oh babe. Thats young to lose your Dad.
I have found that I can have scary dreams about my parents. I do not know what they mean.
Your last paragraph includes words that I am afraid to write - but thoughts that I have had as well.
What's worse? Losing someone so early that they remain little more than a shadow in your life, or losing someone later when they leave a huge hole?
Ugh. Your writing is beautiful but now I'm sad.
I think about this a lot--my friend died last year when her son was just barely 7, and he's already so fine without her. As a mother myself, that kind of kills me. But I'm also happy that he's so functional. The way you described your school experience--being "passed around like bruised fruit"--that was poetry. And so spot on (I hate that phrase, spot on, I am NOT Madonna pretending to be British, but I couldn't think of anything else at the moment).
I'm sorry for all of the loss. But also so inspired because look at what you have become in spite of the loss. Maybe because of the loss? I don't know which, I just know that you are great.
The last couple lines just knocked the air right out of me.
So sad and beautiful.
Wow. That ending got me too, in a big way.
And the poster. My mom was the daughter of a farmer, and she told me once that the only day she skipped class in college was to drive home when the cows were being auctioned off. My grandfather had suffered a farm accident just prior to that which left him unable to work anymore. But I'm sure the auction was more painful than the accident itself.
Mad, I really can't get the jumble out at the moment. This was so honest and humbling and from the heart. In the moment my Dad died my life changed forever too. The details are different, but the lingering loss and aftermath are the same.
The poster did me in though and my Dad's book does the same to me - not just for what it represents, but for a lifetime summed up in words.
How do I make my girls understand a man I am now only learning about today?
My dad left when I was young, and I think I saw him last as a child (though we talk now) at about 5 years, and I had about two or three memories, as well. Very little to go on. I'm sorry that you were in that position, but even worse, without the hope of finding him one day. That's also what makes me so sad about Naylor's Alice books - that she doesn't remember her mother, who doubtless loved her beyond measure. I worry so much more about my own safety now that I have a young girl to be here for. How desperately sad not to be remembered by someone you gave your heart to, through no fault of your own. And how sad, too, to not remember someone who would have played a big role in your young, young life. Hugs, Mad.
when my dad died i was a much older 21. but the dreams i had for about a year afterwards were horrific. they were violent dreams of murders and monsters and blood and guts and putrid death. i'd wake nauseous and terrified and heartbroken.
those ones are gone now. now i just see him sometimes, in the background, happy and smiling.
alive.
oh man, i gotta sign off. the tears are coming fast.
thanks for sharing this mad, i know it is hard in so many ways.
xoxo
it's sad to think of our children losing us so completely.
I'm sorry you've lost so much of your father.
Oh, Mad, I identified with a lot of this post. As others have said, it was haunting and beautiful. The photo is so striking.
I have yet to really write my own feelings about my my father's death when I was 6, and my collection of memories of him.
The end of your post also moved me deeply. I think daily of my friend who died recently, leaving behind her little girls of 3 and 5. It hurts to think how little they may remember of their mother's love for them.
My aunt is dying and I keep thinking of her youngest kid (she has 4) and how bitter he is going to be -- that the others had all that time with her, and he didn't. I hoped I was wrong in thinking that, but I'm not wrong, am I? He will be bitter.
I shouldn't comment now, it's too late & I'm too tired ... but I felt I had to say *something.* You always write from the heart, Mad.
The story of our fathers never ends. I lost my dad when I was
six. I remember the mugs that were set on the table the night he never came home. He drowned on our property checking his traps. I have a great step-father who is like Fred Flinstone, strangely enough, and a cross with Al Pacino. My dad though, what can I say, the handfull of things I remember. There is a deep and moist imprint of him on me, that at times keeps me looking back and at others, as scared as hell to look forward. Nicely written.
That last paragraph? I've seriously never considered that before, not in that way, although I also blog, in part, to make some record for Swee'pea... and now my breath is gone with an ache.
Many, many hugs...
I love my Dad so very much. This adoration I think was destined but also came at a horrible cost. My best friend growing up had to be my older cousin. K. older by 2 years lost her dad to an idiotic, accidental plane crash when she was three.
My family relocated to the town where my Mum's sister was this new widow and we created a tight and precious group.
What did K. know of her Dad? What did she recall was something I never thought of; till now. She told me I know but I wasn't listening. She wasn't entirely either; always an archaeologist, seeking and surmising the facts from the debris.
She is a wonderful mother like you.
This is quite the post.
Oh Mad,
I'm sorry. The farm sale poster is just heartbreaking, catastrophic in its own right.
I understand your response on the other blog. I tend to couch BIG EMOTIONAL PERSONAL STUFF in the public policy issues I recognize in them. It isn't that I'm closed off from it, but its easier to express, not like the big messy octopus in a box my own experience is.
My heart goes out to your mom, and your siblings too.
Mad, this post made me want to hold you as a kid...and now, too...for that fear that you express for Miss M. Any time I even remotely consider the possibility of my passing away now that I'm a mother, my heart starts palpitating.
I, like so many others, found this post so incredibly moving.
Mad,
I remember so clearly a dream I had where my father came back (to life) and was a royal pain in the ass, bossing us around getting in our business, blocking our every moves until one day I screamed at him "WE DON'T NEED YOU!!! WE DO JUST FINE WITHOUT YOU!!!"
I felt tremendous guilt after that dream because in all honesty I think my dream mirrored what I felt in my waking hours but could never ever admit. I'd never wish him away, but some of the struggle I had with his death came from the complicated man that he was in life.
Weird, complicated, hard, sad. Thanks for a really beautiful post.
Thank you! I am planning a post about memory and this is pure Mad gold.
And a wonderful tribute to your dad. Your daughter will love this. And all of your writing. If you were to die tomorrow, your blog would be enough, more than enough, to give her the essence of what you are.
I wish I had more time to just read your posts. You often make my day.
Hugs,
M
ps I can't believe you ever wrote a petulant word in your life. So there.
I have a lot of faith in the enduring quality of the memory we are unaware of - for good and for bad.
What a great post. You have beautifully expressed what so many of us have gone through. I was 15 when my dad died, much older than your 7, but nonetheless I have lost so many of my memories of him. I get along fine without him now, and the fact makes me sad. Life is transient; we are transient; our effect on others is transient.
Your daughter looks a lot like you :) And I guess that's one way we impact future generations. Another is by the things we leave behind. I've gotten to know my dad a bit from his artwork and writings. I only wish I had more.
"Until now I have been her everything and yet, if I died tomorrow, she would simply cease to remember me one day--not just my smell or the sound of my singing but everything about me and my love for her."
I think about that too. And it haunts me. What perfect words and what a beautiful post.
I second the mama bird diaries.
My father's mother died when he was about 4. He's just coming to terms with it now, in his 70's. I ache for him to not have known her, and I ache for her to have been taken away from her children so soon.
I wish for you a peaceful place to keep your memories.
Post a Comment